Overdrive troubleshooting help.
Hey all, my 51 Pacemaker has Drivemaster and O/D and I started driving this car a few weeks ago and the O/D worked fine. Then after several days of driving it worked intermittenly and a few days later stopped working altogether. The fuse is good and I can hear the O/D relay drop out when I slow down to under 20 mph. The governor has 5 wires on it and the kickdown switch & O/D relay have plugs. I straight wired a fused wire to the large terminal on the solenoid and can hear it click kinda softly but still O/D does not work. Any ideas are greatly appreciated, thanks. Richie.
0
Comments
-
Low voltage? I believe the paul has to be shoved down to engage the sun gear, maybe needs all 6 volts? Also, possibly has developed a weak ground?0
-
Richie
Some resources: http://www.tocmp.com/manuals/trans/Borg-Warner%20Overdrive/index.htm
http://www.studebaker-info.org/tech/transmission/BW-OD/BorgWarner.html
The second reference allows you to download a copy of the OD service manual... it has troubleshooting information.
Good luck0 -
Richie wrote:Hey all, my 51 Pacemaker has Drivemaster and O/D and I started driving this car a few weeks ago and the O/D worked fine. Then after several days of driving it worked intermittenly and a few days later stopped working altogether. The fuse is good and I can hear the O/D relay drop out when I slow down to under 20 mph. The governor has 5 wires on it and the kickdown switch & O/D relay have plugs. I straight wired a fused wire to the large terminal on the solenoid and can hear it click kinda softly but still O/D does not work. Any ideas are greatly appreciated, thanks. Richie.0
-
Thank you guys, I'll start first thing in the morning. I appreciate all your comments. Richie.0
-
If the voltages check out, remove the cover from the solenoid and check the contacts and clean them. There should be a couple of contacts. Disconnect the battery FIRST.0
-
When you hot wired to the big terminal on the solenoid, did you drive the car that way to see if it would drop into OD?0
-
dougson wrote:Low voltage? I believe the paul has to be shoved down to engage the sun gear, maybe needs all 6 volts? Also, possibly has developed a weak ground?
Dougson, thanks for your comment, I checked the grounds and cleaned them. That will help prevent future problems. O/D still not working though. Richie.0 -
WildWasp wrote:Richie
Some resources: http://www.tocmp.com/manuals/trans/Borg-Warner%20Overdrive/index.htm
http://www.studebaker-info.org/tech/transmission/BW-OD/BorgWarner.html
The second reference allows you to download a copy of the OD service manual... it has troubleshooting information.
Good luck
WildWasp, thanks for that info. I do have an overdrive manual and had checked several of their suggested troubleshooting ideas to no avail yet. Richie0 -
walt's garage-53 wrote:The first thing you do when OD gives a problem is to check out the output of the generator. The generator feeds the electrics to the overdrive. You must have 6.7 volts to 7.2 and at least 20 amps. Battery does not feed OD. Walt.
Walt, I checked the voltage at idle and again at 800 rpm. Idle was 6.3 volts and 800 rpm was 7.3 volts. I don't have an amp gage so I can't check that. The engine spins over very fast when starting it and the battery was new last year. Thanks Walt. Richie.0 -
SuperDave wrote:If the voltages check out, remove the cover from the solenoid and check the contacts and clean them. There should be a couple of contacts. Disconnect the battery FIRST.
SuperDave, I haven't gotten that far yet but will check that tomorrow, it did however blow the 30 amp fuse today on my last test drive. Thanks SuperDave, Richie.0 -
Richie, what precisely is the problem? When you push the knob in (to enable overdrive), then get up to roughly 30 mph and release the accelerator, it does NOT click into overdrive? Yet it continues to free-wheel?
If this is the case, I'm curious: when you push the knob in, is there any clearance between the back of the knob, and the "stop" (the plate in which the knob shaft runs)? Or does the knob bottom out against the plate?0 -
Park W wrote:When you hot wired to the big terminal on the solenoid, did you drive the car that way to see if it would drop into OD?
Park, I ran a 10 gage wire directly to the solenoid while I had the car jacked up and it seemed to pull in pretty hard. I was afraid to leave that wire on and test drive it so I installed a new old stock headlight relay and ran it to the solenoid. I have a jumper wire going between the two terminals on the solenoid and the 10 gage wire connected to the large terminal. On my last test drive the O/D pulled in for a split second and then pulled out. At that point it blew the 30 amp fuse.
I'm guessing that maybe the solenoid is bad or I wired something wrong, like maybe I don't need the jumper wire. I don't have a spare solenoid but could take the one off my 50 Pacemaker that I know is good and try that. I'll start back on it tomorrow. Thanks Park, Richie.0 -
Jon B wrote:Richie, what precisely is the problem? When you push the knob in (to enable overdrive), then get up to roughly 30 mph and release the accelerator, it does NOT click into overdrive? Yet it continues to free-wheel?
If this is the case, I'm curious: when you push the knob in, is there any clearance between the back of the knob, and the "stop" (the plate in which the knob shaft runs)? Or does the knob bottom out against the plate?
Jon B You are correct about it not going into O/D and just keeps free wheeling. When I push the o/d knob in it still has about an eight of an inch before it hits the stop plate.
Although on my last test drive I felt the o/d kick in for an instant and that was it. When I got home it had blown the 30 amp fuse. Maybe the solenoid is shorted or something. I'll start back on it tomorrow. Thanks Jon B, Richie.0 -
Park is far more knowledgable on the single lever transmission OD wiring than I am. But, you mentioned in your first post about the governor having 5 wires going to it. That seems very odd to me, it should have only one - and it should be a ground.
The solenoid has two hot circuits in it. A heavy "Pull-in" coil that has a very heavy amp load to it, and a "hold in" coil that is self activated by the plunger movement. The heavy Pull-in coil is only supposed to be hot long enough to place enough pressure on the lock up pawl to move and engage, once its made its stroke and the OD is engaged, this movement is supposed to actuate a set of contacts internal to the solenoid and switch the amp load from the pull-in to the hold-in windings. It sounds to me like your "hold-in" coil is staying energised and the amp load is blowing your 30 amp fuse. I don't know how much amperage the pull-in coil is supposed to draw, but it was never meant to be a constant load on any circuit in the car.
I seem to think you have two problems going on. The high amp load of the pull-in coil requires a much better ground than the hold-in coil. All of the problems I've had with the OD system stem from the quality of the grounds. The lock out switch and the governor are subject to get oil in them and interfere with the grounding quality of their contacts. I wouldn't surprize me if perhaps your solenoid is suffering from the same oil related problem and has disabled the "hold-in" contacts.
Park also gave a real good lesson on installing the OD solenoid a few years ago. If its not installed correctly, it can't make a full stroke and would cause the internal contacts not to operate also.
I hope some of that helps you. I'd chase the grounds and contacts from the governor back to the OD relay first, then focus on the solenoid. Park and I disucssed the Solenoid's amp draw a few years ago by e-mail, but we never did put a number on the amp draw of the two solenoid coils. In a properly switching circuit, the amp draw of the pull-in just bounces the amp meter and it settles at the hold-in amperage.
One more item on OD setups that your mopar buddy Pete aka "blueskies" ran into. There is another set of contacts in the solenoid that run to the point side of the coil. Upon Kickdown, the kickdown switch will close a ground circuit through a set of contacts in the solenoid, effectively grounding the igntion circuit and by-passing the points. When the solenoid makes its upstroke to disengage, it breaks these points and full voltage goes back to the distributor. If you remember, he fused the ignition circuit and everytime he "kicked-down" it would blow that fuse and his car would die. The amperage spike caused by the direct short would blow his fuse and kill the ignition circuit. This direct shorting will also kill a Pertronix unit absolutely dead - never to arise. The addition of a normally closed relay to complete the ignition hot side and opens through the former kickdown ground will fix that problem and keep a Pertronix unit isolated from a direct ground.
Mark0 -
`Hudsonator wrote:Park is far more knowledgable on the single lever transmission OD wiring than I am. But, you mentioned in your first post about the governor having 5 wires going to it. That seems very odd to me, it should have only one - and it should be a ground.
The solenoid has two hot circuits in it. A heavy "Pull-in" coil that has a very heavy amp load to it, and a "hold in" coil that is self activated by the plunger movement. The heavy Pull-in coil is only supposed to be hot long enough to place enough pressure on the lock up pawl to move and engage, once its made its stroke and the OD is engaged, this movement is supposed to actuate a set of contacts internal to the solenoid and switch the amp load from the pull-in to the hold-in windings. It sounds to me like your "hold-in" coil is staying energised and the amp load is blowing your 30 amp fuse. I don't know how much amperage the pull-in coil is supposed to draw, but it was never meant to be a constant load on any circuit in the car.
I seem to think you have two problems going on. The high amp load of the pull-in coil requires a much better ground than the hold-in coil. All of the problems I've had with the OD system stem from the quality of the grounds. The lock out switch and the governor are subject to get oil in them and interfere with the grounding quality of their contacts. I wouldn't surprize me if perhaps your solenoid is suffering from the same oil related problem and has disabled the "hold-in" contacts.
Park also gave a real good lesson on installing the OD solenoid a few years ago. If its not installed correctly, it can't make a full stroke and would cause the internal contacts not to operate also.
I hope some of that helps you. I'd chase the grounds and contacts from the governor back to the OD relay first, then focus on the solenoid. Park and I disucssed the Solenoid's amp draw a few years ago by e-mail, but we never did put a number on the amp draw of the two solenoid coils. In a properly switching circuit, the amp draw of the pull-in just bounces the amp meter and it settles at the hold-in amperage.
One more item on OD setups that your mopar buddy Pete aka "blueskies" ran into. There is another set of contacts in the solenoid that run to the point side of the coil. Upon Kickdown, the kickdown switch will close a ground circuit through a set of contacts in the solenoid, effectively grounding the igntion circuit and by-passing the points. When the solenoid makes its upstroke to disengage, it breaks these points and full voltage goes back to the distributor. If you remember, he fused the ignition circuit and everytime he "kicked-down" it would blow that fuse and his car would die. The amperage spike caused by the direct short would blow his fuse and kill the ignition circuit. This direct shorting will also kill a Pertronix unit absolutely dead - never to arise. The addition of a normally closed relay to complete the ignition hot side and opens through the former kickdown ground will fix that problem and keep a Pertronix unit isolated from a direct ground.
Mark
Mark, that is great information, better explained than the manual. I took the solenoid off this morning and took it apart. I cleaned the contacts and put it back together and put it back in the car. It has rained all day here so I have not tried it yet. The only thing that makes sense to me is that the hold-in coil is not working so the constant pull-in coil voltage causes the fuse to blow. There is nothing else in the circuit except the relay that energizes it, as I have by-passed all else at this time. If it doesn't work now, I will take the solenoid out of the 50 and use that to see what happens.
I think that the 5 wires on the governor are connected to the "drivemaster" in some way because the 50 only has one wire on the solenoid. And yes I do remember Pete- blueskies going through some overdrive problems quite a while back. Thanks again Mark for explaining everything. Richie.0 -
Richie, I've made some tests since Hudsonator and I talked some time back. The pull-in coil on your solenoid should draw 20 amps, so shouldn't blow a 30A fuse. You might have a bare spot on one of the two wires going to the solenoid. Check those wires closely. Or there could be a fault in the solenoid that's grounding the pull-in circuit somehow. Remove the solenoid cover and look closely at the wiring inside. Oil on the internal contacts for the pull-in coil wouldn't cause this ... if those contacts don't "make," the solenoid won't pull in. Try this: push the OD button full in. Rig a hot wire with a 30A fuse in the circuit, and a separate short jumper wire. Disconnect the normal wires at the solenoid. Use the short jumper wire to connect the hot wire to the hold-in terminal on the solenoid. You shouldn't hear anything happen. Now momentarily touch the end of the main hot wire to the pull-in terminal. You should hear the expected "clunk." Now remove the hot wire from the pull-in terminal. You should hear nothing, since the hold-in coil is doing its job. Now remove power from the hold-in terminal, and you should hear the clunk as the solenoid "drops out." And of course, the fuse shouldn't blow during this procedure. If all happens OK, the solenoid is likely not the problem.
On the Pertronix issue, Pertronix told me years ago, in response to my query, that grounding the "distributor side" of the coil will not harm their unit. A Dixie Chapter friend wired his Hornet that way and never had a problem. Of course they may have changed something such that the earlier guidance isn't valid any more..0 -
Park W wrote:Richie, I've made some tests since Hudsonator and I talked some time back. The pull-in coil on your solenoid should draw 20 amps, so shouldn't blow a 30A fuse. You might have a bare spot on one of the two wires going to the solenoid. Check those wires closely. Or there could be a fault in the solenoid that's grounding the pull-in circuit somehow. Remove the solenoid cover and look closely at the wiring inside. Oil on the internal contacts for the pull-in coil wouldn't cause this ... if those contacts don't "make," the solenoid won't pull in. Try this: push the OD button full in. Rig a hot wire with a 30A fuse in the circuit, and a separate short jumper wire. Disconnect the normal wires at the solenoid. Use the short jumper wire to connect the hot wire to the hold-in terminal on the solenoid. You shouldn't hear anything happen. Now momentarily touch the end of the main hot wire to the pull-in terminal. You should hear the expected "clunk." Now remove the hot wire from the pull-in terminal. You should hear nothing, since the hold-in coil is doing its job. Now remove power from the hold-in terminal, and you should hear the clunk as the solenoid "drops out." And of course, the fuse shouldn't blow during this procedure. If all happens OK, the solenoid is likely not the problem.
On the Pertronix issue, Pertronix told me years ago, in response to my query, that grounding the "distributor side" of the coil will not harm their unit. A Dixie Chapter friend wired his Hornet that way and never had a problem. Of course they may have changed something such that the earlier guidance isn't valid any more..
Park, I had been gone all day and when I got home this evening I went straight to the garage and took the o/d solenoid out of the 50 and put it in the 51 and it works great right now. I put the original wires back in place when I changed the solenoid. I will check the wiring carefully tomorrow as you suggested to make sure it is in good shape. I hadn't read your message until I was all finished. I will test the solenoid in question tomorrow using your information, that sounds like a great way to make a quick determination whether the problem is the solenoid or you need to look elsewhere. Thanks very much Park, Richie.0
This discussion has been closed.
Categories
- 36.9K All Categories
- 102 Hudson 1916 - 1929
- 17 Upcoming Events
- 90 Essex Super 6
- 28.5K HUDSON
- 556 "How To" - Skills, mechanical and other wise
- 992 Street Rods
- 150 American Motors
- 172 The Flathead Forum
- 49 Manuals, etc,.
- 75 Hudson 8
- 43 FORUM - Instructions and Tips on using the forum
- 2.8K CLASSIFIEDS
- 597 Vehicles
- 2.1K Parts & Pieces
- 77 Literature & Memorabilia
- Hudson 1916 - 1929 Yahoo Groups Archived Photos